Gift Cards: The Cheapest Holiday Marketing a Pizzeria Can Run

Restaurants are the number one gift card people plan to buy this holiday season. If your cards aren’t on the counter and on your ordering site right now, that money is going to the pizza chain down the road.

Your customers are already shopping for them

Gift cards aren’t a niche ask. In the National Retail Federation’s 2025 holiday survey, gift cards were the No. 1 gift people wanted. And when NRF asked what kind of gift card shoppers planned to buy, restaurants topped the list at 27%, ahead of bank-issued cards and department stores.

Tighter budgets help you here. Blackhawk Network’s 2026 holiday study found that 82% of shoppers are setting a holiday budget, and 93% of those budget-setters plan to buy gift cards. A $25 card from the pizza place everyone in town knows is an easy line item for the kid’s coach, a teacher, or the neighbor who plows the driveway.

Why it’s the cheapest marketing you’ll run

Let’s take a look at what most holiday promotions actually cost. A 20% off coupon gives away margin on every order it touches, including the ones you would have gotten anyway. And a paid ad costs money whether the phone rings or not. With gift cards, here’s what you get back:

Cash now. Restaurant gift card sales are about as seasonal as it gets. Paytronix, which tracks gift card sales for restaurant brands, reports that November and December make up 45% of annual restaurant gift card sales. And the money comes in whether the gift card is redeemed or not (more on that later).

A referral you didn’t pay for. Word of mouth is a powerful sales tool. Your regular customer is putting your pizza in front of someone who potentially hasn’t tried it yet. That recommendation costs you nothing and comes from someone they already trust. All you have to do is make sure that first pizza is a good one.

A bigger ticket later. Blackhawk Network found that nearly 60% of shoppers spend beyond the value of a gift card, with an average upspend of $73. Nobody walks in with a $25 card and orders exactly $25. They add the wings, upgrade to a large, and grab a two-liter of soda, because it feels like someone else is paying.

Traffic when you want it. Gift cards get used in the weeks after the holidays, when the phones are quieter and the schedule is easier to fill. That’s money you already collected in December walking back through the door in January, keeping your crew busy when they’d otherwise be sent home early.

Of course, not every gift card gets used. Bankrate’s 2024 survey found 43% of Americans are holding at least one unused gift card, worth $244 on average. That’s not the win, though. The redemption visit is where the new customer and the bigger ticket come from (and hopefully that trip leads to many more visits to your store).

Six ways to sell more gift cards this season

Bonus: none of these require discounting your pizza.

  1. Ask on every order. “Want to add a gift card for anyone on your list?” One line at the counter and on the phone, every order through December. That’s the whole script.
  2. Put them on your ordering site. A banner at the top of your online ordering menu works best. Digital cards also catch the last-minute shopper who’s buying at 11 p.m. on December 23. Send one text to your list when the cards go live.
  3. Sell small denominations. $10, $20, and $25 cards make good stocking stuffers and teacher gifts. Blackhawk found cards of $50 and under drive the most upspend, and 74% of shoppers would spend more than the value of a $10 card.
  4. Run a bonus offer. Buy $50 in gift cards, get a $10 bonus card. Make the bonus a separate promo card that’s good from January through March. It rewards the buyer and brings them back after the holidays. Check your state’s rules on promotional cards before you set the dates.
  5. Go after bulk orders. Local businesses buy gift cards for employees and clients. Coaches buy them for teams. Start with the offices that already order lunch from you.
  6. Stuff the bag. Every delivery and carryout order through December should leave with a small card or flyer about gift cards. You’re already handing customers something. Use it as an opportunity to bring them (or someone they know) back.

Where to start

You don’t need a new campaign. You just need gift cards on the counter, digital gift cards on your website, and a phone and counter crew that asks. With HungerRush gift cards, you can sell branded digital and physical cards built right into your POS and online ordering, so a card bought on someone’s phone works at your counter.

And don’t forget, if you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it. Know how many you sold, how many came back, and what those guests spent on top of the card. That’s how you’ll know whether the bonus offer paid for itself and which denominations to stock next year. HungerRush makes this easy by tracking redemptions and balances in the same system as the rest of your sales, so you’re not chasing numbers across a separate tool.

Want to see how gift cards, online ordering, and your POS work together? Book a demo.